Nathan/Sarah

[officerparker]

I think it's about time we made this thread considering all the theories regarding them and Sarah in general

I'm going to reply to other posts here:

I've certainly been wrong about things before. And I hope that if Nathan and Sarah are together, that it's done in a way I can swallow. To me, they are not the same person. But like I said, the whole star-crossed lovers, destined to be together in different times thing doesn't really work as a trope for me. I'm definitely a nurture over nature kind of person.

I hope you're right about Duke!

ETA: And I also hope that if you're right, and Nathan/Sarah happens, that we find out Nathan broke it off with Jordan after last week.

Well I do love the whole star-crossed lovers where they fall in love no matter when or how and Nathan/Audrey seems to touch right on that. And nature and nurture don't need to be unrelated. To me it seems that Nathan and Audrey are a bit of both. They may be star crossed lovers, but their relationship is also built on.

I have very wild theories concerning Sarah/Lucy/Audrey (and Nathan/Audrey/the girls in general) so whenever I say something it's always assuming my crazy and wild theory is half right.

I find a hard time believing they'd have Nathan and Sarah sleep together so easily when Nathan, completely in love with Audrey, hasn't stepped up his game. Something has to happen to make him get so close to Sarah so quickly. Nathan's not the kind of guy to take whatever he can get, so he wouldn't "betray" Audrey like that because Sarah's available. From the promo is clear he's going to try and help save Sarah, so I wonder if maybe their proximity and interaction doesn't "trigger" memories in Sarah, where she remembers being Audrey, remembers Nathan, etc. I'm really hoping for a twist here, so I'm going to have faith and trust the writers until I watch (and I can genuinely wank and rant if need be )

It seems they cut the Jordan/Nathan scene from last week's episode, so maybe it was a break up. If it is indeed a break up, I'm positive Nathan's going to tell Audrey.

I agree. I think at the end Audrey is Sarah as much as she was Lucy. Since she can now feel being Lucy, I think she might feel being Sarah too.
I don't know If Nathan is going to sleep with her, but I am sure this episode will be a turning point for pretty much everyone.

I completely agree! Maybe Sarah's even already pregnant And she isn't wearing any rings neither in the promo, behind the scenes, gag reels and promo pics, so the ring Vince gave Audrey must have come after 1955 and Duke and Nathan's visit.

[valfromrome]

.Something has to happen to make him get so close to Sarah so quickly. Nathan's not the kind of guy to take whatever he can get, so he wouldn't "betray" Audrey like that because Sarah's available.

I agree. It would be so OOC of Nathan to sleep with her just because she looks like Audrey. I also wonder if Nathan remembers everything from the present in the 1955 or his memories are somewìhow erased.
I don't think this is going to be a option, but if he doesn't remember Audrey and falls for Sarah, it enforces the idea that their love is something that overcome everything.
I know...I'm just dreaming about epic love.

It seems they cut the Jordan/Nathan scene from last week's episode, so maybe it was a break up. If it is indeed a break up, I'm positive Nathan's going to tell Audrey.

Didn't know about that, but I count on the fact that when the synopsis said that Nathan is going to set things right in the present, it was meant for him to be honest with Jordan and break up whatever they have.

I completely agree! Maybe Sarah's even already pregnant And she isn't wearing any rings neither in the promo, behind the scenes, gag reels and promo pics, so the ring Vince gave Audrey must have come after 1955 and Duke and Nathan's visit.

Yep about the ring...I wonder how old was Garland Wournos in 1955? He had to be a kid or so....

Also why the Teagues said that they needed Garland back in S2?
From the promo it looks like he is back...

[officerparker]

Nathan has his memories, they don't get erased.

I think Garland was just a little kid. If he was a rookie in 1983 then he was in his early 20s, which probably means he was either just being born or he wasn't born yet?

Yeah he's back because whatever they're doing in the past is changing the present, so maybe that means Garland never became Chief? If he never had the stress of keeping the town together he wouldn't have blown up.

[valfromrome]

Nov 14, 2012 14:44:24 GMT -5 officerparker said:

Nathan has his memories, they don't get erased.

I think Garland was just a little kid. If he was a rookie in 1983 then he was in his early 20s, which probably means he was either just being born or he wasn't born yet?

Yeah he's back because whatever they're doing in the past is changing the present, so maybe that means Garland never became Chief? If he never had the stress of keeping the town together he wouldn't have blown up.

Good point. I still wonder about what Vince meant when they decided to keep the cooler. What do they know? Once the troubles go away, can garland come back?

[officerparker]

Imagina Garland getting himself back together LOL. I really liked him so I'd love to see him back.

[dordoris]

I also agree it's cute the idea of them falling in love no matter which memories, hair or name. But in this case it's not like Audrey went away and he finds her again as a different person (Sarah), he just time traveled. That's why I am not entirely happy with Nathan getting in bed with her, unless she has some memories of Audrey or something... But I don't know yet, lets see how they'll work this out.

[killabeez]

Nov 15, 2012 16:29:58 GMT -5 dordoris said:

I also agree it's cute the idea of them falling in love no matter which memories, hair or name. But in this case it's not like Audrey went away and he finds her again as a different person (Sarah), he just time traveled. That's why I am not entirely happy with Nathan getting in bed with her, unless she has some memories of Audrey or something... But I don't know yet, lets see how they'll work this out.

Dordoris, I'm glad I'm not the only one who feels this way. I'm definitely willing to wait and see how it plays out—I do trust the writers to a certain degree. But I hope they make it work for me.