I'd posted this in the ring conjecture thread already, but anyway, it relates more to this. It's a speculation post I recently made on my tumblr. I'm sorry it's rather long (and crazy)
“I have always loved you”: The crazy Haven theory(Warning! Contains big spoilers for episodes 7 through to 9) SO, I’ve been thinking really hard about various unsolved mysteries on Haven right now. Who is the Colorado Kid (James Cogan)’s father? What’s going to happen to Nathan? Why did Nathan’s dad have that ring? Why did Dave give Audrey that (very similar) ring?
Then after the crazy revelations from the latest episode, re-analysis of that Behind the Scenes Video and the Gag Reel, reading other fans’ speculation and some very enlightening spoilers for upcoming episodes 8 and 9, some crazy connections have begun to form in my head!!
The facts are these (warning again!! spoilers!!):
1. Obviously, Nathan is not going to stay dead. We’ve seen promo photos from episode 8.
From the BTS video too:
2. The description of the episode says: “Episode 3.08 - Magic Hour (Part 2) Audrey and Duke return from Colorado; Audrey, Duke and Tommy try to find the woman with the resurrection touch.”
They will obviously find Moira (we’ve seen Audrey with her in the promo), and she will resurrect Nathan. Fingers crossed that Audrey will express her emotions again, not only when he’s (momentarily) dead!!
3. This is where it gets really interesting. the description for the next episode says “Episode 3.08 - Sarah: Duke gets taken back to 1955; Nathan tries to find a way to rescue Duke from the past and to set things right in the present.”
4. The writers and cast have been going on about this episode having huge reveals, as well as it being a big NathanxAudrey episode! They all kept reassuring fans before the season began, that even though we were going to go through some hard times with Nathan and Audrey, we will be rewarded, and very happy in the later half of the season. I think all fans can agree that we’ve gone through more than enough heartache with these two and I only see the good coming up now.
5. I find it very interesting as we’ve also seen (from the BTS video and blooper reel released before the start of the season), Nathan in the past with Sarah!
6. In the promo for episode 8, Audrey says ‘I have always loved you’ Could she mean something else unconsciously?? Like in past lives, for example??? I just read from a fan on fanforum that:
“Honestly the writers did say they were going to be able to do a love through time theme and no other show could do it.”How interesting! This is reaching way too far, but this is supposed to be a speculation post anyway, so I’m just going to go there! We just found out Sarah is in fact the Colorado kid’s mother. But we don’t know who his father was. There is the possibility it’s Dave, since it seems he and Sarah had something OR there’s this crazier, more fabulous theory! I remember when episode 4 aired, a couple of people were commenting that the Colorado Kid (that we saw in the Lucy flashbacks) looked a lot like Nathan.
Also, the ep. description says Nathan tries to save Duke, who is in 1955. i.e Nathan is going to 1955. The Colorado Kid was born in 1956.
Dave gave Audrey Sarah’s ring, which is probably a wedding band. A writer on the show (Nick Parker, I believe) tweeted a fan confirming Sarah was married.
Nathan has a (very similar) ring that he took from the cooler with his dad’s remains. He wears it around his neck like his dad used to.
Could it be possible, somehow, Nathan in the past gave Chief Wuornos to keep it for him??? In the BTS video for season 3, we see a flash of Nathan and The Chief together.
The Chief is supposed to be very much dead, so I’m wondering, could this be when Nathan is moving around in time in episode 9?? He gives him the ring? (But then again Chief Wuornos actually looks older here, so it doesn’t make sense that Nathan this could have been in the past, because the chief wears the ring from the start of season 1. However, it also doesn’t make sense that it’s in the future, because, like I said, the chief’s very much dead. Then again, this is Haven, so… Also, it looks like this is actually from episode 10 or 11, because of the swamp.)
You see where I’m going with this…..
could the Colorado Kid be Nathan and Sarah/Lucy/Audrey’s son?? This is, ofcourse, pure speculation. All just very ridiculous fangirl theories and there are lots or loops and holes in it, but whatever. This is why I love Haven- there are so many layers and hints to the story you can make various connections (which probably aren’t right), and it’s lots of fun. I do wonder, if Audrey/Lucy/Sarah usually stays only a few months, how long was she pregnant?? And why is he Colorado Kid's name Cogan? Who is this Cogan person?? Is it a fake name or his actual dad's surname??
On a last, unrelated note: Here are some other screen caps from the BTS and blooper videos that I found very interesting:
And this has been warping my brain all week:
I’m probably jumping too far again, but is it just me or does that little girl look a helluvalot like Audrey? Now this, I can’t even begin to imagine how it fits in, so I won’t bother. It’s from the BTS video, and I know Lucas Bryant has a daughter, so maybe that’s her just visiting him on set? But she seriously looks like Emily Rose! The hair of course, and the jawline, and the eyes and everything!
So here is the end of this (ridiculous ludicrous unlikely presumptuous improbable bizarre absurd outrageous preposterous idealistic quixotic) theory. I’m not the first or only person to have this idea- this is like a compilation of data and my opinion on it. And I can’t lie; this is all coming from a hyper Naudrey shipper that is way too excited by that promo!!